Comparing Pillow Top and Regular Mattresses: Which is Best for You?
When it comes to purchasing a new mattress, deciding between a pillow top mattress and a regular mattress can be challenging. Pillow top mattresses contain an additional upholstery layer over the regular mattress, providing a luxuriously plush feeling. A regular mattress, on the other hand, offers a more stiff and firm feel. To ensure you get the best mattress for you, it’s important to understand the differences between a pillow top and regular mattress and consider the benefits and drawbacks of both.
Understanding Pillow Top and Regular Mattresses
A pillow top mattress, also known as a Euro-Top or Plush-Top, has an added layer of upholstery affixed to the top of the mattress. This layer contains either synthetic or natural fibers, like wool and cotton, to give the mattress a luxuriously soft feel. It also contains layers of foam and fiber filling for added cushioning. Pillow top mattresses are usually quite comfortable, however after some time the upholstery layer can become compressed or lumpy as the mattress wears down.
On the other hand, a regular mattress has a single, uniform layer of springs or foam that has been put together in one piece. Regular mattresses tend to give off a stiffer and firmer feel than pillow top mattresses. These mattresses are very durable, as the springs or foam are built to last, though in comparison to pillow top mattresses, a regular mattress may not be quite as comfortable.
When it comes to choosing between a pillow top and regular mattress, it is important to consider your own personal preferences. If you prefer a softer, more luxurious feel, then a pillow top mattress may be the best choice for you. However, if you prefer a firmer mattress that will last for many years, then a regular mattress may be the better option.
It is also important to consider the cost of the mattress. Pillow top mattresses tend to be more expensive than regular mattresses, as they are made with more materials and require more labor to construct. However, if you are looking for a mattress that will provide you with a comfortable night’s sleep, then the extra cost may be worth it.
Benefits of a Pillow Top Mattress
The most significant upside to a pillow top mattress is its luxurious comfort. The added layer of upholstery is extremely soft and gives off a plush feeling that is unparalleled. Pillow tops can also provide better pressure relief for joints by allowing the body to mold into its shape more easily. This is especially beneficial for people who suffer from chronic pain or muscle tension. Furthermore, pillow top mattresses provide additional cushioning for improved neck and back support.
Pillow top mattresses are also great for those who tend to sleep hot. The extra layer of upholstery helps to keep the mattress cooler by providing an extra layer of insulation. This can help to reduce night sweats and keep you comfortable throughout the night. Additionally, pillow top mattresses are often more durable than traditional mattresses, as the extra layer of upholstery helps to protect the mattress from wear and tear.
Finally, pillow top mattresses are often more affordable than other types of mattresses. This is because the extra layer of upholstery is usually made from cheaper materials, which helps to keep the cost down. This makes pillow top mattresses a great option for those who are looking for a comfortable mattress without breaking the bank.
Benefits of a Regular Mattress
Regular mattresses provide a particularly good option for those looking for a more firm sleeping surface. They are much more durable than their pillow top counterparts, and they provide excellent orthopedic support due to their even distribution of pressure throughout the body. This can be beneficial for those suffering from sciatica or arthritis. Regular mattresses are also much easier to turn over, making them ideal for those who tend to move around a lot while they sleep.
Regular mattresses are also a great choice for those who are looking for a more affordable option. They are typically less expensive than pillow top mattresses, and they can last for many years with proper care. Additionally, regular mattresses are often easier to clean and maintain, as they don’t have the extra layers of padding that pillow top mattresses have.
Cost Comparison of Pillow Top and Regular Mattresses
When comparing the price of pillow top mattresses and regular mattresses, pillow tops are usually more expensive. This is due to the elegant nature of the extra upholstery layer that a pillow top mattress has. That said, budget friendly options do exist for those looking to purchase a lower-cost mattress.
When shopping for a pillow top mattress, it is important to consider the quality of the materials used. Higher quality materials will result in a longer lasting mattress, and may be worth the extra cost. Additionally, it is important to consider the size of the mattress. Pillow top mattresses are available in a variety of sizes, and the cost may vary depending on the size.
When comparing the cost of a pillow top mattress to a regular mattress, it is important to consider the long-term benefits. Pillow top mattresses are designed to provide extra comfort and support, and may be worth the extra cost in the long run. Additionally, many pillow top mattresses come with a warranty, which can provide peace of mind when making a purchase.
Durability Factors for Pillow Top and Regular Mattresses
When it comes to durability, regular mattresses typically last longer than pillow top mattresses. The added layer of upholstery on pillow tops can easily wear down after an extended period of use. This can lead to indentations forming on either side of the person sleeping on it. The springs or foam in regular mattresses, however, can withstand more wear and tear, meaning they typically last longer.
Regular mattresses are also more cost-effective than pillow top mattresses. The extra layer of upholstery on pillow tops can add to the cost of the mattress, making them more expensive than regular mattresses. Additionally, the extra layer of upholstery can also make pillow top mattresses more difficult to move and transport.
When it comes to comfort, pillow top mattresses are often preferred over regular mattresses. The extra layer of upholstery on pillow tops can provide a softer, more comfortable sleeping surface. This can be beneficial for people who suffer from back pain or other physical ailments. However, regular mattresses can also provide a comfortable sleeping surface, depending on the type of mattress and the type of foam or springs used.
Comfort Levels of Pillow Top and Regular Mattresses
When it comes to comfort level, pillow tops do generally feel softer and plusher than regular mattresses. This is mainly attributed to the additional upholstery layer that comes with them. That being said, comfort level is largely subjective and depends on personal preference. For those who prefer a more firm sleeping surface, a regular mattress is likely the better choice.
Pros and Cons of Pillow Top and Regular Mattresses
Pillow Top Mattress Pros:
- Extra upholstery layer for plush feeling
- Better pressure relief for joints
- Additional cushioning for improved neck and back support
Pillow Top Mattress Cons:
- Can wear down over time
- More expensive than regular mattresses
Regular Mattress Pros:
- Firmer feel than pillow top mattresses
- Excellent orthopedic support due to even distribution of pressure throughout the body
- Easier to turn over due to one-piece springs or foam design
Regular Mattress Cons:
- Less comfortable than pillow top mattresses
- May not provide adequate support for those with chronic pain or muscle tension
How to Select the Right Mattress for You
Choosing between a pillow top mattress and a regular mattress comes down to personal preference and budget. Those who prefer a softer sleeping surface may benefit from a pillow top mattress, while those looking for firmness may benefit from a regular mattress. Individuals with chronic pain or muscle tension should opt for a pillow top mattress for its superior pressure relief capabilities, while those with back or neck ailments should opt for a regular mattress for its orthopedic support.
Tips for Maintaining Your Pillow Top or Regular Mattress
No matter which type of mattress you finally decide on, following these tips can help increase its longevity:
- Flip your mattress every 6 months to ensure even wear over its lifetime.
- Vacuum your mattress regularly to help prevent dust mites.
- Rotate your mattress 180 degrees annually, or every 6 months if you have a pillow top mattress.
