Comparing Pillow Top and Plush Mattresses: Which is Right for You?

Do you want a mattress that will fit your unique body and lifestyle needs? There are many different types of mattresses available, but it can be hard to know which type is right for you. Pillow top mattresses and plush mattresses are two popular types of mattresses, but what are the key differences between them? In this article, we’ll explore the key differences between pillow top and plush mattresses, what each type of mattress offers in terms of comfort, pros and cons of each, and whether a pillow top or plush mattress is right for you.

Key Differences between Pillow Top and Plush Mattresses

The main difference between pillow top mattresses and plush mattresses is the feel. Pillow top mattresses are slightly softer than plush mattresses and provide a softer, more cushioned surface. Pillow tops also tend to be thicker than plush mattresses, as they have an added layer of padding on the top. Plush mattresses, on the other hand, are firmer and provide more support as they tend to be thinner than pillow tops. Plush mattresses also offer a slightly more buoyant feel than pillow tops.

When it comes to price, pillow top mattresses tend to be more expensive than plush mattresses. This is due to the extra layer of padding that is included in the pillow top mattress. Additionally, pillow top mattresses require more maintenance than plush mattresses, as the extra layer of padding can become compressed over time and require fluffing or rotating to maintain its shape and comfort.

When it comes to durability, plush mattresses tend to be more durable than pillow top mattresses. This is because the extra layer of padding in the pillow top mattress can become compressed over time, leading to a decrease in comfort and support. Plush mattresses, on the other hand, are more resistant to wear and tear and can last longer than pillow top mattresses.

What is a Pillow Top Mattress?

Pillow top mattresses are one of the most popular types of mattresses on the market. Pillow tops have an additional layer of cushioning on the top of the mattress, which makes them softer than other types of mattresses. Pillow tops are usually made with an innerspring core and a fluffy top layer of foam, wool, or cotton. Many pillow tops also come with euro-style toppers which provide an extra layer of support and comfort.

Pillow top mattresses are great for people who want a softer sleeping surface, as the extra layer of cushioning helps to reduce pressure points and provide a more comfortable sleep. Pillow tops are also great for people who suffer from back pain, as the extra cushioning helps to support the spine and reduce discomfort. Pillow tops are also great for people who tend to sleep hot, as the extra layer of cushioning helps to keep the mattress cooler.

When shopping for a pillow top mattress, it is important to consider the type of material used in the top layer. Foam and wool are the most common materials used in pillow tops, and both provide excellent cushioning and support. Cotton is also a popular choice, as it is breathable and helps to keep the mattress cool. It is also important to consider the thickness of the pillow top, as thicker pillow tops provide more cushioning and support.

What is a Plush Mattress?

Plush mattresses are a type of mattress designed to provide a medium amount of support and comfort. Plush mattresses typically have a thinner thickness than pillow tops and are often made with a combination of innerspring coils, memory foam, or latex. Plush mattresses are slightly firmer than pillow tops, so they may provide better support for people with back pain. Plush mattresses are also great for those who prefer the feel of a firmer mattress.

Plush mattresses are often recommended for side sleepers, as they provide enough cushioning to keep the spine in alignment while still providing enough support. Additionally, plush mattresses are often more affordable than other mattress types, making them a great option for those on a budget. Plush mattresses are also easy to maintain, as they don’t require flipping or rotating like other mattress types.

Pros and Cons of a Pillow Top Mattress

Pillow top mattresses provide many benefits, including softer support, more cushioning, and added comfort. They’re great for those who prefer a softer sleep surface or who want added cushioning for their body. The downside is that pillow tops tend to be thicker and take up more room in the bedroom than other types of mattresses. Additionally, due to their added layers of padding, pillow tops may not be as breathable as other mattress types.

Pillow top mattresses also tend to be more expensive than other types of mattresses. They also require more frequent flipping and rotating to ensure even wear and tear. Additionally, the extra padding can cause the mattress to sag over time, leading to a decrease in comfort and support. It’s important to consider all of these factors when deciding whether a pillow top mattress is the right choice for you.

Pros and Cons of a Plush Mattress

Plush mattresses offer several advantages, including additional support for back pain relief, a medium-level feel for those who want both support and comfort, and breathability due to their thinner profile. Plush mattresses may not offer as much cushioning as pillow tops, so they may not be ideal for those who prefer a softer sleep surface. Additionally, they may not be as durable as some of the other mattress types.

On the other hand, plush mattresses are often more affordable than other mattress types, making them a great option for those on a budget. They also tend to be lighter than other mattresses, making them easier to move and transport. Finally, plush mattresses are often more customizable than other mattress types, allowing you to choose the exact firmness and support level that you need.

Considerations to Make before Buying a Pillow Top or Plush Mattress

Before making any purchase, it’s important to consider several factors before deciding which type of mattress is right for you. Consider the size of your bed, your budget, the firmness level you prefer, any health issues you might have that could affect your sleep, and how often you plan to use the mattress. Additionally, if you’re buying online, be sure to read customer reviews so you can get an idea of how others have felt about their mattress purchase.

It’s also important to consider the type of material the mattress is made of. Different materials can affect the comfort level of the mattress, as well as its durability. For example, memory foam mattresses are known for their comfort and support, while innerspring mattresses are more affordable and can provide a firmer sleeping surface. Ultimately, the type of mattress you choose should be based on your individual needs and preferences.

Is a Pillow Top or Plush Mattress Right for You?

The decision between a pillow top and plush mattress ultimately comes down to preference. If you prefer the feeling of sleeping on something softer and more cushioned, then a pillow top mattress may be the way to go. On the other hand, if you’re looking for more support and a medium-firm feel, then a plush mattress may be more suitable. Ultimately, it’s important to try out different mattresses in person before making any purchase.

When shopping for a pillow top or plush mattress, it’s important to consider the type of material used. Pillow top mattresses are usually made with a combination of foam and fiberfill, while plush mattresses are usually made with a combination of foam and innerspring coils. It’s important to consider the type of material used, as this will affect the overall comfort and support of the mattress.

It’s also important to consider the size of the mattress. Pillow top and plush mattresses come in a variety of sizes, from twin to king. It’s important to choose a size that will fit your bed frame and provide enough space for you to sleep comfortably. Additionally, it’s important to consider the weight of the mattress, as heavier mattresses may be more difficult to move and adjust.

Other Types of Mattresses to Consider

There are many other types of mattresses available that may benefit you depending on your individual needs. Memory foam mattresses are well-known for their contouring support that can help relieve your pressure points. Latex mattresses are great for those who want a natural sleep surface with plenty of bounce. Hybrid mattresses are perfect for those who want the best of both worlds with a combination of coils and foam/latex layers.

Conclusion

Pillow top and plush mattresses are both popular types of mattresses that may suit different needs depending on your preferences. Pillow tops provide more cushioning and softer support than plush mattresses, while plush mattresses offer more support and breathability due to their thinner profile. Consider your budget, sleeping position, health issues, and firmness preferences before making any purchase. To get the best night’s sleep possible, test out different types of mattresses in person to find what’s right for you.